Time to Pull the Plug: Why South Africa Should Ban Facebook

South Africa already knows how quickly a rumour can become a mob. Facebook has made that faster, cheaper and harder to stop.

Look at the past year. False information has flourished amid heightened xenophobic tension and anti-migrant protests in 2026, with fake police notices shared on Facebook and Instagram. A fake “Home Affairs” poster ordering all “illegal foreigners” to leave by 30 June circulated on Facebook, X and TikTok, and police had to debunk it. Research by the non-profit Tales of Turning found that 27% of anti-foreigner misinformation was linked to coordinated networks. This is not ordinary people arguing. It is manufactured outrage, and the platform’s reach rewards it. south africa ignore fake warning against renting immigrants +2

The platform’s own safeguards are weakening. One journalist has warned that Meta’s retreat from fact-checking has helped groups like Operation Dudula fuel xenophobia. Global Witness found that Meta lost hundreds of content moderators even as it approved violent hate-speech adverts in South Africa. A company that will not police itself cannot expect the country to keep absorbing the damage. ewnglobalwitness

Then there are the scams. Fake Facebook profiles using FNB’s name to offer loans are designed to steal personal information. The Education Department has warned of “teacher assistants” job scams on the platform. In a country with severe unemployment, fake jobs and fake loans prey on the most desperate people. africacheckallafrica

Our courts have said that freedom of expression is not protected where it incites harm, and rights must respect the dignity of others. A platform that repeatedly fails that test, despite reports, forfeits its claim to operate here. A ban would be a proportionate response to a company that treats South African safety as a cost to cut. dailymaverick

The other side of the argument

Critics of a ban make serious points. Millions of South Africans use Facebook for family contact, community groups, and small businesses with no website. A ban would hit informal traders and rural users hardest. Banning one platform would likely push people toward WhatsApp, TikTok or VPNs, where the same content circulates with less visibility. Press freedom groups also warn that blocking a major platform sets a precedent governments can abuse. Many argue that enforcing existing hate-speech law, demanding local moderation, and fining platforms would do more good without cutting off access.

Oh hi there!!
It’s nice to meet you.

Subscribe to receive awesome content in your inbox, every Monday at 08:00.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.